Stack & Associates, P.C.
Contact Our Office Environmental and Land Use Law

EPA faces legal challenges over recent Clean Air Act rule

The Georgia Coalition for Sound Environmental Policy and the Georgia Industry Environmental Coalition are among the groups challenging a rule under the Clean Air Act which requires states to remove civil penalty shields from their pollution reduction plans. The penalty shields are known as affirmative defense provisions, and they apply in only in certain circumstances.

While EPA initially permitted states to have such provisions for purposes of Clean Air Act compliance, the agency was successful in passing a rule disallowing them back in May. The rule was issued after the EPA found that 36 states do not adequately address deficiencies in compliance with emissions requirements during periods where the plans were either beginning to be implemented, or are shut down or malfunctioning due to unavoidable equipment malfunctions. The rule specifically requires states to remove provisions that protect facilities from being hit with civil penalties for violations in such circumstances. 

Many of the legal challenges have to do with the EPA’s authority in passing the new rule. Among the legal issues being raised by various groups are whether the EPA must first make a finding regarding the impact of compliance inconsistencies on air quality standards before taking the kind of action it did, and whether the Clean Air Act requires states to implement a continuous restriction on emissions without any exceptions. Groups in Texas are asking the court to consider whether the EPA acted arbitrarily and capriciously in finding that the state’s plan was inadequate without first demonstrating that affirmative defense provisions, in themselves, prevent states from coming into substantial compliance with requirements under the Clean Air Act.

Georgia groups have also asked the court to consider several legal questions. In our next post, we’ll consider these issues and speak a bit about the importance of environmental compliance

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Our Firm

In the legal profession as in other fields, past accomplishments are often the best indicators of future success. Our representative cases bear witness to our law firm's ability to represent clients against even the most formidable adversaries, including government bodies and giant corporations, in both individual and class action claims.

Email Us For A Response

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Our Office Locations

260 Peachtree Street N.W.
Suite 1200
Atlanta, GA 30303

Phone: 404-692-7504
Fax: 404.522.0275
Map & Directions

23 Delegal Rd
Savannah, GA 31411

Phone: 404-692-7504
Phone: 912.232.0567
Fax: 404.522.0275